Dilemma.

I just recently ran out of my favorite eyeliner (K-Palette 1-Day Tattoo - Limited Edition) and now I can't decide which eyeliner to buy.
I bought the 1-Day Tattoo one on sale for $13, such a steal! Now, I can't decide between the Dolly Wink, Original 1-Day Tattoo, or the Kiss Me - Help! ):
They're all about the same price so I'm looking for quality here. :3